Search This Blog

Sunday, September 17, 2006

Belmont Club: "Book 'em Danno "

The government of Pakistan has released thousands of Taliban fighters.

Via Belmont Club we get this from the Telegraph News

Pakistan's credibility as a leading ally in the war on terrorism was called into question last night when it emerged that President Pervez Musharraf's government had authorised the release from jail of thousands of Taliban fighters caught fighting coalition forces in Afghanistan.

The mass release of the prisoners has provoked a stern rebuke to the Musharraf regime from the American government. "We have repeatedly warned Pakistan over arresting and then releasing suspects," said a US diplomat in Islamabad. "We are monitoring their response with great concern."


Click on the link to find who was included in the release.

But Richard Fernandez asks:

Some of these individuals may never have been charged or prosecuted in a way that would satisfy "International Law". By that standard, they should be released. Grant the premise, grant the conclusion. What I want to know is how this prisoner release is different in principle from the policy advocated by critics of Guantanamo prison. I am sure there must be some difference. But the question remains. How should prisoners captured on the terrorist battlefield be treated and how long should they be detained?


I know what my opinion is of this release, but I am afraid that that ACLU has an opposite opinion.

No comments: