I hope that I’m not misunderstanding Ann Althouse when quote
her but when I read this I was immediately struck by the amazing amount of
preening going on. The subject is Dan
Quale’s comment surrounding the unwed parentage of “Murphy Brown.” For those too young to remember the character
was the lead in a situation comedy show named after her who had a child without
being married. Dan Quayle, then Vice
President, tried to make the point hat having children without being married
was not a good idea. He was pilloried by
members of the media for (1) being mean to unmarried mothers who everyone knew
were just as good as married mothers and (2) referring to a fictional character
as a role model.
Ann Althouse is “pushing back” against the belief that
Quayle was right in his comments because … well I – as a long time reader of
her blog – think that in her view, nothing that she’s for is wrong. For example, here is her comment regarding
her position:
Look at what is being admitted. There are a whole lot of people who are insufficiently smart, competent, and emotionally stable to make a decision involving a complex set of factors, so we need to dominate their minds with a starker structure of "right" and "wrong," even where those of us who are really smart and able to process complex factors know it's not really a matter of right and wrong.
Putting it in other words: people who are not as smart as Ann may be having babies out of wedlock so they have to be brainwashed into thinking that they are doing wrong. The really smart people know that those stupid moral rules are for simpletons. We can create our own rules because we are “really smart.”
Not to pick on Ann, but I have noticed the tendency of
people on the Left to be sinless in their own eyes. Ann has a homosexual son so to her the issue
of gay marriage is not open to debate.
To her it’s human rights issue that’s clear-cut; her son should not be excluded
from the military or from matrimony.
Ann voted for Obama and that wasn’t a mistake; it’s not her
fault that Obama has turned out to be the kind of President that the Right
predicted.
The Christian view of humans is the belief that we are all
fallen creatures, prone to sin, in need of Christ’s redemption. Ann Althouse prefers to believe that she’s a
very good judge of good and evil and if her view come into conflict with
religious doctrine or millennia of human experience, her view is superior because
she’s one of “.. those of us who are
really smart and able to process complex factors.”
No comments:
Post a Comment